What the Pentagon Says About the 3M Earplug Lawsuit – Cochran Law
Legally Reviewed and Edited by: Terry Cochran
Hearing loss is not an evitable cost of war. For the Pentagon prevention of hearing loss is critical, as noise exposure is inevitable due to the nature of the profession, and hearing is a vital asset during combat or training. The 3M Earplug Lawsuit was filed under the whistleblower (qui tam) provisions of the False Claims Act, and the company settled for $9.1 million to resolve allegations without admitting liability.
Hearing loss and tinnitus, including loss of balance, is the most common military injury in combat veterans, and unfortunately, it is often the unseen damage or injuries that gets the least attention but creates the most problems for military staff or veterans.
What is the 3M Earplug Lawsuit?
3M, a Minnesota based company, purchased Aearo Technologies, Inc., and supplied the US Military dual-ended Combat Arms Earplugs, version 2 (CAEv2) under contract, claiming it met the military standards required.
They claimed their earplugs would protect the ears of military personnel from noise pollution above 85 decibels while allowing them to hear voices. This includes typical combat noise such as military vehicles and other operational noise, loud explosions, and close-range firearms.
The earplugs were standard-issued equipment for soldiers serving between 2002 and 2015, in Afghanistan and Iraq, and most military bases.
In a highly publicized case, under qui tam (whistle-blower) provisions of the False Claims Act, the United States Military alleged 3M knew the CAEv2 earplugs were defective and did not meet the military standards. It was alleged that both companies were aware of the design flaws, defects, and failed tests.
In particular, they alleged that the earplugs were:
- Too short for proper insertion into most users’ ears
- The plugs would often loosen imperceptibly
- Did not perform correctly for many individuals
- The defects negated the effectiveness of hearing protection,
- Exposed thousands of military personnel to hearing loss and tinnitus
- Did not disclose this design defect to the military
It was claimed that Aero Technologies, Inc. tested the earplugs in early 2000 and it showed a zero-noise reduction rate (NRR), which means it offered no protection against noise that can damage hearing and cause tinnitus. Despite these failed tests 3M claimed it met military standards.
Why is Hearing Loss Protection Critical in the Military?
Hearing Loss is the Number One Service-oriented disability in post-combat personnel; however, most people would suspect it to be lost limbs or traumatic brain injuries, or even Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome (PTSD) as these are the cases that are publicized.
Noise pollution is a recognized occupational hazard in the military; most personnel are exposed to some form of prolonged noise pollution at some stage, whether you are on active duty, in combat zones, or working in noisy environments amongst military equipment.
Exposure length and type will vary – some are exposed to constant noise pollution over an extended period. For others, while in active combat or training exercises, it will be the ongoing noise generated by military vehicles as well as regular gunfire, booming, and extremely loud noises.
The CDC estimates that military veterans have a 30% higher chance of hearing problems.
The VA (U.S. Department of Veteran Affairs) reports that nearly 3 million veterans receive disability benefits for tinnitus and hearing loss.
NIH funded studies show that active combat can increase the risk six-fold (63%).
Current service personnel records show that 10-18% have been diagnosed with significant threshold shifts in their hearing despite efforts to improve military hearing conservation programs (HCPs).
The CDC estimates that military veterans have a 30% higher chance of hearing problems than non-veterans, and despite efforts to improve military hearing conservation programs (HCPs) 10-18% of Service personnel have been diagnosed with significant threshold shifts in their hearing.
Effects of Noise Pollution
The biggest problem with noise pollution injuries and damage is the fact that it is often not reported and thus not treated, as it cannot be ‘seen’ as you would for example in a loss of limb. The effects of noise pollution are pervasive, persistent, and numerous. It is medically and socially significant.
There is the perception or sensation of sound or ringing in the ears where no external sound is present. Tinnitus is not a condition, but a symptom of an underlying condition such as hearing injury or loss and often gets worse with age.
Short or long-term exposure to loud and booming noises can cause permanent damage to the inner ear hair cells. These move in relation to the pressure of soundwaves and will then trigger electrical impulses to your auditory nerve, which the brain then interprets as sounds.
The phantom sounds are heard in one, or both ears will come and go. Sometimes it is so loud and pervasive that it will interfere with your ability to hear an actual sound or to concentrate. It may include ringing, buzzing, clicking, humming, roaring, and hissing, which may vary in pitch.
Noise-Induced Hearing Impairment
A blow to the head, chronic and prolonged exposure to loud noises, or sudden bursts of noise at high decibels, can cause permanent damage to normal hearing. Hearing impairment is typically defined as an increase in the threshold of hearing, according to the WHO (World Health Organization), and is assessed by threshold audiometry.
Threshold tests are compared to a baseline test in occupational settings.
Hearing loss is defined as
- conductive (outer and middle ear)
- sensorineural (inner ear)
- Difficulty understanding words against background noise
- Muffling of speech or other sounds
- Struggling to hear woman’s or kid’s voices,
- Trouble hearing consonants
- Needing volume on tv, phones or radios turned up
- Withdrawal from social activities
Any patient with combat-related head trauma must be evaluated for possible blast-related comorbidities, including speech or language problems, dizziness and imbalance, and PTSD.
A very high instantaneous sound pressure level or a blow to the head can cause severe mechanical damage to the ear:
- Interference with Speech Communication – can cause problems with speech comprehension, cognitive and mental functioning, human relations, as well as several stress reactions.
- Activation of the autonomic and hormonal systems, which produces increased heart rate, blood pressure, and vasoconstriction, which may precipitate hypertension and ischaemic heart disease associated with exposures to high sound pressure levels.
- Other Physiological, Social, and Emotional Impacts – some long-term effects may be devastating and affect the overall quality of life. This may include fatigue, stress, anxiety, memory problems, sleep deprivation, and an inability to relax. Due to the effects on your employment options, family and social relationships, it may even lead to isolation, depression, and eventually cognitive decline.
What Causes Tinnitus and Hearing Loss in the Military
Exposure to noise is inevitable in the military due to the nature of the profession. Prevention of hearing loss is key, as hearing is a vital asset in all military operations, be it tactical and survival training or actual combat.
The constant exposure to high levels of noise, often for extended periods, makes adequate prevention paramount. Combat can increase the risk of hearing loss six-fold, or 63%, according to an NIH study.
Earplugs are the centerpiece to the prevention strategy and should always be used when exposed to noise levels above 85 decibels.
Effective earplugs can reduce noise levels by 30 plus decibels. This is very much dependant on the length of exposure as every 3-decibel increase in loud noises halves the time one can be exposed to the noise without damage
Consider the steady background noises of a Black Hawk helicopter at 106 decibels or a Bradley Fighting Vehicle 130 decibels compared to a grenade at 160 decibels or an AT4 antitank weapon which booms for a second at 187 decibels.
Military personnel have little option but to remain at their posts despite the constant barrage of noise above safe levels.
Hearing Loss Associated with US military Combat Deployment
Wells et al. defined the risk of hearing loss among US Military members in relation to their deployment experiences, in a study published in Noise & Health. Data from the Millennium Cohort Study and Objective Military Service Data was used to assess exposures and outcomes.
The main findings include that:
- Combat experience was associated with a 63% increased risk for hearing loss
- The hearing injury was more likely to be reported if the person was exposed to a blast or suffering combat-related head trauma
The study recommended that prevention should include early detection and monitoring.
Impact of Noise on Hearing in the Military
The sources of noise in the military, pathophysiology, and management of patients with noise-induced hearing loss were evaluated in a study published in Mil Med Res in 2015. The results of this study highlight the staggering risks military personnel face daily, mandating the use of impeccable prevention methods.
Sources vary with designations, with the strongest determinants of hearing loss being:
- Combat-specific occupations
- Fighting in Built-up Area (FIBUA) training
- Military exercise participation
- Shooting with large caliber weapons
According to the OSHA 2014 Standards permissible noise exposure in the workplace, measured in duration per day (hours) based on sound level (dBA), ranges from:
- 8 hours for 90 dBA,
- 2h for 100 dBA,
- ¼h or less for 115 dBA
Peak Sound Pressure Level for different weapons are all much higher:
- Rifles: 155-163 dBA
- Shotguns: 151-161 dBA
- Pistols: 151-163 dBA
- Hand grenade: 158 dBA
- Light anti-tank weapon: 184 dBA
- Continuous noise inside an armored vehicle: 103-107 dBA
Pilots often exhibit hearing impairment due to chronic exposure.
- Service helicopters
- Gazelle 97 dBA
- Scout 99.8 dBA
- Puma 99.9 dBA
- Lynx 100 dBA
- Black Hawk 106 dBA
- Fighter planes 97-104 dBA
- Jet trainers 100-106 dBA
- Transporter aircrafts 88-101 dBA
The highest indoor noise levels were found in the engine rooms:
- landing ship tanks and patrol vessels at 98-103 dBA
- missile gunboats 120 dBA
- on carrier decks from 130-160 dBA
Clinical presentation includes:
- Temporary threshold shifts
- Abnormal pitch perception
- Tinnitus, increased sensitivity (hyperacusis)
Treatment – prevention is still the recommended treatment.
The Pentagon and the 3M Hearing Lawsuit
Frank Robey, Director of the US Army Criminal Investigation Command’s Major Procurement Fraud Unit, announced that 3M Company, headquartered in St. Paul, Minnesota, had agreed to pay $9.1 million to resolve allegations that they have knowingly sold defective earplugs, in a press release issued by the Department of Justice in July 2018. The 3M Company, however, did not admit liability.
“Today’s settlement will ensure that those who do business with the government know that their actions will not go unnoticed,” said Robey. “Properly made safety equipment, for use by our soldiers, is vital to our military’s readiness. Our agents will respond robustly to protect the safety of our military.”
“Companies who knowingly hide important information regarding the impact of their products should be held responsible,” according to one of the top personal injury lawyers in Michigan, Eileen Kroll.
The lawsuit was brought under the qui tam (whistleblower) provisions of the False Claims Act. The Federal Act, also known as the Lincoln Law, and several parallel state false claim acts, allows citizens to sue companies on behalf of the government if they have proof of fraud, and to participate in the settlement or award. It is a civil anti-fraud statute designed to allow monetary recovery for the government when defrauded by contractors and to punish those that perpetrate fraud. It is recognized by Congress as a pervasive, expanding and severe national problem.
The main elements of a false claim under the FCA – the claim must be:
- Made knowing that the claim was false
- Material to payment
The military’s case is captioned United States ex rel. Moldex-Metric v. 3M Company, Case No. 3:16-cv-1533-MBS (D.S.C.) but is generally referred to as the 3M Hearing Lawsuit. The settlement was the result of a coordinated effort between several government and military organizations, namely the Army Criminal Investigation Command, the Defense Criminal Investigative Service, The Civil Division of the Department of Justice and the United States Attorney’s Office for the District of South Carolina. All the departments strongly condemned any party that supplies substandard products, in particular to military personnel and stated that they would vigorously defend the military against fraud, waste, and abuse.
Protect Yourself and Your Rights
Hundreds of veterans have filed suit in the 3M Hearing Lawsuit, and you may qualify if you meet the following criteria:
- Served in the US Military between the years 2003 and 2015
- No dishonorable discharge
- No documented tinnitus or hearing loss before or at the time of joining the military
- Documented tinnitus or hearing loss after joining the military
- No history of significant noise exposure outside the military
- Active combat duty
- Working close to high decibel noise for extended periods
Don’t forget about the statutes of limitation If you are a military veteran who lives in Michigan, and you have suffered hearing loss or other noise pollution damage, call Eileen Kroll, a nurse and personal injury trial attorney, at Cochran, Kroll & Associates, at 866-MICH-LAW or fill in the form on our website for a call-back and free case evaluation consultation.
Disclaimer : The information provided is general and not for legal advice. The blogs are not intended to provide legal counsel and no attorney-client relationship is created nor intended.